Looking for Off-Season Hunting Fun? Try Hunting Pigeon!

Thanks for visiting the The Badger's Den (the blog for Badger Ridge).   If an internet search brought you here looking for muzzleloader solutions, please stick with us: we have the solution to your Remington 700 ML/MLS and Ruger 77/50 woes.   I update this blog frequently and what you are looking for is probably one or two clicks away. This blog is sorted categorically and chronologically.   So you can find what you want by looking in the appropriate category, or if you know when it was published, you can use the time line. Or just keep scrolling down!

​If you are new to our site: YES WE STILL SERVICE AND CONVERT THESE OLD MUZZLE LOADERS

But for this installment I'd like to tell you about:

A new product we'd like to share with you!  Pigeon Decoy Shells!

I tend to turn what I've learned from my hobbies into our products.   In this installment I'd like to share a product that helps me better enjoy one of my Off-Season passions: Pigeon Hunting.  We are pleased to offer what I believe is the best compromise between effectiveness, low cost, rapid setup, and portability:   Pigeon decoy shells.

---

A Brief Overview of Pigeon's Origin, Habits, & ID

In the United States: pigeon are feral (non-native).   A long time ago what we call pigeon were domesticated from Rock Doves, and then eventually brought to the US.   Pigeon are raised by many enthusiasts, and released in races and tournaments.  Thus pigeon don't have a huge fear of man and will graze near us and our livestock.   Just like their Rock Dove progenitors who nested in rock cliffs, pigeon are cavity nesters: so they tend to roost under cover, in old buildings with horizontal ledges.  They will hatch and raise young all year round provided there is sufficient feed.  

Being feral, most states don't regulate pigeon harvest, set limits, nor establish seasons.  As feral species compete with native species for resources, most states encourage harvesting them as much as possible, year round.   Check your local regulations to be sure.  Here in Michigan a base (small game) hunting license is required to hunt pigeon, but there are not any seasons nor bag limits.  This makes them excellent off-season fun.

To the untrained eye, pigeon and dove look a lot alike.   The fact that in Spanish the two birds are called by the same name ("Paloma") says a lot about the two. Not to mention the lecture on taxonomy you could get from an ornithologist that would be mixed with the words dove and pigeon referring to closely related birds.  However, it is not hard to learn to quickly distinguish one from the other. ​

Mourning Dove v Rock Dove (Pigeon) image from: birdingpoint.com

Its always important to be able to accurately ID your target.   Especially because mourning dove are a North American native migratory species, regulated federally, and also by each individual state.   Here in Michigan, it is prohibited to hunt mourning dove (which I call 'dove' frequently in this post).   In most other states mourning dove may be hunted in season, with a bag limit, and migratory bird license.  Also many parts of the US have additional types of protected doves.  A hunter must be able to distinguish between them and pigeons.

A pigeon (left) with showy, iridescent colors vs. a drab brown mourning dove, Credit: iStock images

Pigeon are larger and more plump.  Mourning dove tend to hang out on power lines, small tree branches, and will nest without a roof.  You will find pigeon sitting on ledges,  roof peaks, etc.  Though they will sit on powerlines too.  If you see a pigeon in a tree, it most likely will be closer to the trunk on the fatter part of the branch.  The two have drastically different calls.  When flying mourning doves tend to sound squeaky, while pigeons have a flapping 'rapid clap' sound, especially when they light or land.  I find pigeon wing beats to be erratic and 'floppy' while dove are more rhythmic and snappy.  When lighting or landing, its easy to see a pigeon's 'squared off' tail compared to a mourning dove's spearhead shape.  There isn't much variety to the dove's dull brown speckled plumage.    A pigeon may look like the examples here, or have various white, auburn, and other color variations.

Note all the color variations in these harvested pigeon

Pigeon, just like dove, taste great (I was fortunate enough to live in states where I could shoot dove).  The meat is called "squab."  Notably squab can also refer to their young... aka pigeon/dove 'chicks'.   It can also be a raw pigeon breast in super fancy restaurants!   I don't recommend eating any meat raw!  Their meat is frequently referred to as 'filet mignon of the sky' by us rednecks, as they have dark breasts that when removed look and taste like little slices of back strap.

Like waterfowl, pigeon tend to have daily routines.  I've found hunting pigeon to be much more like hunting the feed for waterfowl than any upland bird.  First, they start their day at the roost,  hungry.   Unlike freshwater waterfowl, they probably thirst along with their hunger.   Having worked their way through the contents of their crop all evening (the expandable pouch in their neck where they store food), they are hungry in the mornings.  If they have young, they need to find food then return to the roost to feed them  (both the male and the female tend to the young).   Somewhat unique to pigeon, siblings will also participate in feeding their younger kin.  So once daylight has arrived, they fly off the roost in search of food, and sometimes water.  They may return quickly or stay out for the day.  

With pigeon, hunting the roost is fun and can be very successful, especially after they have fed and desire to return to the roost.   But most roosts are close to man, and/or man's livestock.  So hunting the roost may not be an option.    That typically leaves us hunting the feed.

Like many waterfowl, their preferred feed is cut crops.   Modern mechanical harvesting has been a blessing to these seed feeders:  A portion of the crop is lost and spread over the harvested field.  You will tend to find pigeon there.  In late summer look for cut wheat,  in Fall add harvested corn and soy beans to the list.   Also, pigeon will go to roads and other areas with small gravel to get grit for their gizzard.  But I've not seen them stay there for long.  I've also seen pigeon feed off of spread cow manure.   It seems they find the undigested seed in the manure and are happy to pick through it. 

In my area the Amish plant and harvest organic wheat.  Their old-school process of cutting, binding, stacking, drying, and then bringing the wheat in hardly loses a seed.  I rarely see pigeon on their cut wheat fields, but I've found them in their silos, and livestock watering holes.   One Amish family really likes it when I bring them walleye...  you will almost certainly have to talk with the eldest male to get permission.   If you are a man,  don't expect Amish women/girls to say much to you.

---

How to Hunt Pigeon

 A successful pigeon hunt will probably involve: 

-1. Scouting where they roost:  look for buildings, silos, grain bins, with cover and access holes in the sides.   If you see pigeon on the edge of a roof or opening, chances are there are more inside.

-2. Finding the available feeds, watering holes, and grit.   You will probably find the same feed used by dove, ducks, and geese.  You do want to observe pigeons on the feed to know what field they are in using.  I've seen plenty of fields filled with dove that pigeon pass right by.  Sometimes finding pigeon is easy, other times you have to sit a while to determine their movement.

-3. Getting access: Once you see their patterns, and understand their daily life, try to get access to those places, set up a hide with decoys, and be ready for fancy flying!   Bringing a kid along has improved the number of landowners I've gotten "YES" from.

Pigeon are very social birds.  I've watched pigeon bypass a very good feed to join a flock on another field with poor feed.  The only reason I could come up with for the behavior was a socially driven need to congregate.  Thus hunting the feed or waterhole is all about setting up visible decoys in the right spot and getting a little bit of cover.

---

More Specifics on our Decoys

I've found our decoy shells just plain work.  They are a great balance of effective, light weight, portable, and quick setup/breakdown.  Each shell comes with a stake that make them a bit higher than a standing pigeon. This is good: it increases visibility.  You want your decoys above any stubble or vegetation that could block them from view.  When the shell is sitting on the stake they also have a little bit of a bobbing motion.  This is pronounced when facing into or directly out of the wind.  The decoy shell has two rectangular holes for the stake.  Using  the forward hole pivots the shell upwards: like a standing erect pigeon.  Using the back hole pivots it downward like its feeding.   You can set your spread as you like.   I like to set mostly feeders with one erect.   Also, when hunting really tall stubble, you can omit the stake and set the shell right on top of the stubble!

Pigeon aren't all that smart: they don't need 100% perfect reproductions to be decoyed by them.   Moreover, due to domestication, there are so many variations to their plumage there is no such thing as 100% accurate decoys.   But again decoys are sold to hunters, not birds!  While there are other much more expensive, less portable,  finely painted decoys out there: they are not any more effective.  I'd argue they are probably less effective because they are smaller,  shorter, and don't bob in the wind like our shells.  The flat card silhouettes featuring pictures of pigeon are also inferior to our shells.  Remember: Effective decoys must 'look like' pigeons from all angles and not be covered up by stubble so they can be seen.​

Example of our Dark Pigeon color scheme (above)

I've played with patterns while hunting and I've settled on two simple ones:  Light and Dark.   Most pigeon plumage are a variation of our dark theme.   The lighter plumages are recessive traits, thus you only want a few of the light theme in your decoy spread.  Hence, our 6 pack of shells comes with 5 dark theme, and 1 light theme. ​

This is the prototype version of the light decoy shell. The production version will vary slightly.

I am confident that you will find our shells work. They are bigger than a normal pigeon.  Waterfowlers will quickly recognize that is a good thing.  The better decoys in waterfowl hunting are also bigger.  Size matters:  bigger means that the decoys can be seen from further away.  Birds are fine with giants: So long as the giants look like pigeons, pigeons will decoy to them.

More importantly, because they are shells, they stack together for easy portability.   And because they are shells, they are lightweight.  6 shells and their stakes weigh about 2 pounds.  I easily fit 6 to a dozen shells with stakes in my game vest's pouch (with tons of room for dead pigeons).   When I need to move,  I pack my spread and am  gone in under 5 minutes...   only carrying a few extra pounds. 

My "one man on the go" pigeon rig is very simple:
1: 6 of our decoy shells & their stakes
2: a camo dove stool
3: a box or two of #8 or #7 1/2 shells & a shotgun*
4: boots, camo game vest, clothes, & hat
5: a bottle of water
​
*when you know there are birds there, bring lots of shells, and perhaps another half dozen decoys!

---

How I hunt with our Pigeon Decoy Shells

I set my decoy shells about 20 paces out from a bush, fence row, high stubble, or other cover.  If I can find shade in the summer I'll sit there!   Sitting in the shade while the birds fly in the sun helps hide the hunter.  While pigeons aren't as wary as many other game birds, you will have more success wearing camo, hiding, and blending in.   Blinds aren't required, but you can use one if you want.  A blind certainly won't hurt.   For me, it is better to be mobile than to have a fancy blind.

​My typical hunt goes like this:  if its early AM, I set up where I think they will feed.   I find bushes, fence lines with trees,  etc that I can place my dove stool.    Sitting on the stool looking at the decoys, I make sure I have my back to the the wind.  Always ensure a 300 yard safety zone out front beyond the decoys.  I put my decoys out about 20 paces in front of me (I'll move them closer if I have a youngster with a 410 hunting with me).   In a light wind I face the decoy shells in all random directions, a yard or more apart.   I place a few into the wind so they bobble.   In a strong wind I set them into or exactly out of the wind.  Smart use of the wind will make them dance!   

I typically won't shoot the roost to start out.  First, folks usually live there and don't want to be woke up by my shooting.   Second, they usually have livestock close by.  Third, once you shoot at the roost, you push all the birds out, and will quickly need to go find where they are feeding anyways.

If I'm on the X (ie where they want to feed) the birds show.  Most all of them decoy, and the shooting begins.  If you leave the roost alone and they stream out randomly on their own, you'll probably get more shots on more birds.  If they are feeding elsewhere, and I can hunt near or on that X, I pick up and move.

Sometimes you can't get on the X due to permission, livestock, etc.  In that case I try to scare the birds out of there if I can.  Then I set up between the X and the roost.  Even if they aren't feeding there, frequently pigeons will at least buzz or pass close to decoys on their way home.

If I'm going out there midday.  I like to drive around and find today's feed.   Then I walk out into the group to break them up.  Sometimes I can get a shot as they flush.   After they are dispersed, I set up the decoys nearby, where I can get a little cover.  Walking into them seems to stir them up and break them up into smaller groups.  When each small group returns and sees the decoy spread, they think:  "Hey! there's where everyone got off to!"  They tend to dive bomb on in like they were on a rope... and the shooting starts!  

Pigeon are skilled, somewhat erratic flyers and can be a challenge to hit.  When I shoot pigeons, I place them in my spread as more decoys.

One of my more frustrating but still successful hunts, the birds wanted to feed on the 40 acres north of the parcel I had permission to hunt.   The parcel the birds wanted to hang out on was run by a commercial farm operation (doesn't allow hunting).   They had cut their wheat (actually 'tricale') early as green feed, and then turned it and spread manure.  The pigeons preferred to pick through the manure, over  gleaning wheat with me and all the doves packed into the adjoining 40 acres.   I admit I was frustrated seeing all those birds I couldn't hunt just out of reach, while having hundreds of dove I couldn't shoot buzzing all around me.  I didn't have access so I couldn't walk in there and break the pigeon up.  I didn't know what else to do, so found good cover as close as I could to the field they wanted to be in, and set my decoys.  It was slow and pickings were slim, but I picked off the occasional curious bird that decided to visit my spread.  A slow but successful hunt is better than no hunt.   If I didn't have decoys, I'm confident I wouldn't have gotten a bird.

---

A Great Youth Hunting Opportunity

As a parting thought,  I'd also like to encourage bringing a junior hunter along (preferably once you have your set-up figured out and can provide them with a good hunt).  Pigeons are pretty forgiving of rookie mistakes, and you can bring them in close to kids just by setting the decoys closer.   Let 'em land in the decoys if they will.  It doesn't get any better for a youngster with a 410.

I give my son first shot... then I bat clean up.

It doesn't take much cover for a Pigeon hunt if you are wearing camo and sit still.

Youth with a 410: Set the decoys close and let the Pigeon land

Don't be surprised when they keep circling the decoys after being shot at.   They are pigeon after all.

Got suggestions?   Lessons learned?  Think I'm full of it?  Did our products help you?   Post a comment below to let us know!